Jump to navigation

The University of Arizona Wordmark Line Logo White
Home
  • Indigenous Governance Database
  • CONSTITUTIONS RESOURCE CENTER
  • Home
  • Key Resources
    • Conferences, Seminars & Symposia
    • NNI and Harvard Project Research
    • Great Tribal Leaders of Modern Times
    • Good Native Governance
    • Indigenous Leaders Fellows
    • Native Nation Building TV
    • Leading Native Nations
    • Emerging Leaders
  • NNI Tools
  • About
  • Contact Us
  • My Library
  • Login
Indigenous Governance Database

From the Rebuilding Native Nations Course Series: "Test: Does Your Nation Have an Independent Judiciary?"

  • Resource
  • Details
  • Citation
  • Transcript

Not Related

Producer: 
Native Nations Institute
Year: 
2012

Rebuilding Native Nations: "Test: Does Your Nation Have an Independent Judiciary?"

Professor Robert A. Williams, Jr. shares a short test to help a Native nation and its leaders and citizens determine whether or not their judicial system is truly independent.

capable governing institutions, independent judiciaries, independent judiciary, judicial independence, separation of powers, sovereign immunity, tribal courts
Share
People: 
Robert A. Williams, Jr.
Resource Type: 
Teaching Cases and Materials
Topics: 
Governance, Justice Systems
Useful Links: 
NNI "Rebuilding Native Nations" Short Course: Justice Systems

Williams, Jr., Robert A. "Justice Systems: Moving Your Nation Forward." Native Nations Institute for Leadership, Management, and Policy, University of Arizona. Tucson, Arizona. 2012. Lecture.

"So, like Miriam, I'm going to ask you to take a test to see whether or not you have an independent judiciary on your reservation. Get out your pens, check yes or no, and we'll tally at the end:

On my reservation, the Chair is related to the Chief Justice -- yes or no?

On my reservation, the Chair is poker buddies with the Chief Justice.

On my reservation, judicial review means the Council can review any judge who makes an unpopular decision and fire him.

On my reservation, checks and balances are something the tribal finance office can't keep track of.

On my reservation, separation of powers means the Council doesn't ask questions about the judiciary's travel expenses, and the judiciary doesn't ask questions about the Council's.

On my reservation, the question of whether the tribe has waived its sovereign immunity is something that only the Council can decide.

Now, if you had six to five "˜no's,' you are very independent, but if you only had one to two, it's kangaroo court city, babe. Where do you stand on that test? And as tribal leaders, you need to engage honestly with this issue of, "˜Are you ready for an independent and strong tribal judiciary?'" 

IGD Database Search

Enter a search term

Quick Links

  • What's New at the Native Nations Institute?
  • Indigenous Governance Program
  • NNI Radio
  • US Indigenous Data Sovereignty Network

Other Useful Resources

Indigenous Peoples’ Good Governance, Human Rights and Self-Determination in the Second Decade of the New Millennium – A Māori Perspective
Tribal General Welfare Exclusion Act Signed into Law by Obama
Taylor Keen: The Disenfranchisement of the Cherokee Freedmen: Assertion or Abuse of Sovereignty?
Anthony Hill: Constitutional Reform on the Gila River Indian Community
Diné (Navajo) Local Governance Projects
  • About
  • NNI Hub
  • Key Resources
  • Constitutions Resource Center
  • Indigenous Governance Database
  • Login

The Native Nations Institute and The University of Arizona make efforts to ensure the information presented is accurate and up to date, but make no claims, promises, or guarantees about the accuracy, completeness, or adequacy of the content contained on this website.  This website's content is the opinion of the specific author, not statements of advice, opinion, or information from The University of Arizona, and contains links to third party sites.  The University of Arizona is not responsible for and neither approves nor endorses third party website content.  Information presented on this website and the registered trademarks, service marks, wordmarks, and logos of the Native Nations Institute and the University of Arizona may not be reproduced without express written permission. 

The University of Arizona respects intellectual property and privacy rights.  Please refer to The University of Arizona's Copyright Notice and Information Security & Privacy policies for more information.


© 2021 The Arizona Board of Regents on behalf of The University of Arizona.